
You're Hiring to Fill a Shift, Not Build a Company
You're Hiring to Fill a Shift, Not Build a Company
Every operator who's ever opened a second location hits the same wall: who's going to run store one while you're building store two? On this episode of the Ride or Die Restaurant Show, Greg Provance and Spiro Douvris tackle one of the most common questions they get from growing operators: when do you promote from within, and when do you hire from outside? Their answer: that's the wrong question. The real one is whether you're deciding from where you're at, or from where you're going.
What's the difference between hiring "from where you're at" and "from where you're going"?
Hiring from where you're at is reactive, filling an immediate gap. Greg describes it directly: "I need a body. I need to cover this shift by Saturday 'cause so-and-so walked out." Those situations are real, but they shouldn't define your hiring strategy. Hiring from where you're going means picturing your business at stores two, three, and four, and asking who in front of you could actually run one of them someday. It's the difference between solving today's problem and building tomorrow's company.
Should you build your org chart around your current people, or around the roles you need?
Greg's rule: build the org chart first around roles and responsibilities, then slot people into it, never the other way around. "Just because somebody's worked for you for ten or fifteen years doesn't mean they're the right person to scale your business beyond where you're at," he says. Organizing around the people you already have, out of loyalty or fear of upsetting them, is how companies end up with roles invented to avoid hard conversations instead of roles that actually serve where the business is headed.
How do you actually decide if a more expensive hire is worth it?
Spiro breaks the math down into something concrete. A $10,000 raise works out to roughly $27.40 a day. The real question isn't whether you can afford the raise, it's whether that person solves $27.40 worth of headaches for you every single day. "Would you pay thirty dollars a day to get rid of that problem?" Most operators, once they see the number broken down that small, say yes immediately, which exposes that the real hesitation was never about affordability. It was about how the number looked written down as an annual salary.
Why do companies like In-N-Out and Portillo's pay managers above market on purpose?
Spiro shares a story from his family's restaurant background: Portillo's founder told his father he pays his managers ten thousand dollars over market deliberately, "because there's a standard and expectations that I demand that they're gonna think twice before not hitting those." In-N-Out runs a similar play with its famously high manager pay. The point isn't generosity, it's design. Overpaying on purpose buys the right to hold people to a standard they can't hit by accident.
What timeline should an operator have in place before opening a second location?
Spiro is specific: the leadership gap has to be solved well before opening day, not the week before. "You need to have that person solidified and in place way before you leave," he says, because once construction starts on store two, the owner's attention physically shifts away from store one. Without a developed leader already running it, store one's performance starts slipping right when the business can least afford it, since a new location typically needs six to fourteen months of runway before it's self-sustaining.
Does a visible growth path actually change who applies to work for you?
Yes, according to Greg, and it compounds. An organization with a real, demonstrated path to growth attracts stronger candidates, because serious performers are evaluating you the same way you're evaluating them. "They're looking to see if their needs are going to get served," Greg says. "These people aren't stupid... they've probably helped design those types of operations" themselves. Build the ladder, and better people show up to climb it.
More from the Rundown: for more on building the leadership bench your growth actually needs, see Are You Building Drivers or Just Babysitting Doers?, Stop Hiring Bodies, Start Hiring Believers, and Stop Selling Territories, Start Building Franchisees.
Knowing exactly when to develop from within, when to hire from outside, and how to build an org chart that can actually scale, that's exactly what we help restaurant owners work through inside the Leadership Circle. If this conversation resonated, learn more about the Leadership Circle here.
Want more conversations like this one? Subscribe to the Ride or Die Restaurant Show and catch every episode at gphospitalitypartners.com/podcast.